Most GOP senators who oppose stimulus are from states that leech off the rest of us


A couple of months ago, I wrote HERE about the fact that Republican states generally are those that get back more in federal spending than they pay in federal taxes.

Such states, in effect, are leeching off the rest of us.  But most of them are represented in Congress by politicians who love to warn against redistribution of the wealth and cry about creeping socialism.

Interestingly, these same hypocritical pols also tend to be opposed to President Obama’s economic stimulus proposal. 

Take, for example, Republican Sens. John McCain and John Kyl (above), both of whom represent Arizona, which gets back $1.19 for every $1 it pays in federal taxes,  according to the LATEST FIGURES available from the Tax Foundation. (The numbers are a little dated, but the patterns have pertained for many years.)

South Carolina does even better than Arizona. It gets back $1.35 for every $1 it sends to Washington. And one of its senators, Lindsey Graham, is a leading GOP spokesman against the stimulus bill.

Another big foe of the stimulus is Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell, who’s from Kentucky, which receives $1.51 in federal spending for every $1 it pays in taxes.

These phonies are from what I call “taker states.” They take from the “giver states,”  states that pay more than they get back.

Illinois is a giver state.  We get back only 75 cents on the dollar from the feds. Yet both of our senators, Democrats Dick Durbin and Roland Burris, are strong supporters of the stimulus bill.

So, the way I figure it, Republican lawmakers must be afraid that the stimulus bill isn’t enough of a giveaway to their states. The Democrats, on the other hand, are trying to save America — all of it, not just their own states — from economic ruin.

POSTSCRIPT: I should note that I borrowed the terms “giver states” and “taker states” from author Daniel H. Pink, who used them in an op-ed column in The New York Times more than five years ago. I subequently used those terms in several columns I wrote for the Register Star, and I credited Pink on those occasions.


1 Comment

  1. Mr. Baseball

    The hypocrisy is astounding. The same is true for Sarah Palin who campaigned against federal spending while Alaska got back far more than it paid in taxes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *