A moderate-conservative says the Republican Party is on the verge of committing political suicide


David Brooks NAILS IT:

It’s beginning to look as though we’re not going to get an immigration reform law this year. House Republicans are moving in a direction that will probably be unacceptable to the Senate majority and the White House. Conservative commentators like my friends Bill Kristol and Rich Lowry are arguing that the status quo is better than the comprehensive approach passed by the Senate. The whole effort is in peril.

This could be a tragedy for the country and political suicide for Republicans, especially because the conservative arguments against the comprehensive approach are not compelling.

After all, the Senate bill fulfills the four biggest conservative objectives. Conservatives say they want economic growth. The Senate immigration bill is the biggest pro-growth item on the agenda today. Based on estimates from the Congressional Budget Office, the Senate bill would increase the gross domestic product by 3.3 percent by 2023 and by 5.4 percent by 2033. A separate study by the American Action Forum found that it would increase per capita income by $1,700 after 10 years.

Conservatives say they want to bring down debt. According to government estimates, the Senate bill would reduce federal deficits by up to $850 billion over the next 20 years. The Senate bill reduces the 75-year Social Security fund shortfall by half-a-trillion dollars.

Conservatives say they want to reduce illegal immigration. The Senate bill spends huge amounts of money to secure the border. According to the C.B.O., the bill would reduce illegal immigration by somewhere between 33 percent to 50 percent. True, it would not totally eliminate illegal immigration, but it would do a lot better than current law, which reduces illegal immigration by 0 percent.

Conservatives say they want to avoid a European-style demographic collapse. But without more immigrants, and the higher fertility rates they bring, that is exactly what the U.S. faces. Plus, this bill radically increases the number of high-skilled immigrants. It takes millions of long-term resident families out of the shadows so they can lead more mainstream lives.


Whether this bill passes or not, this country is heading toward a multiethnic future. Republicans can either shape that future in a conservative direction or, as I’ve tried to argue, they can become the receding roar of a white America that is never coming back.

That’s what’s at stake.



  1. The key now needs to be to get moderate Republicans and progressives in favor of American forms of Proportional Representation as advocated for by FairVote. Then, we can have a winner-doesn’t-take-all electoral system that isn’t afraid of extra minorities tipping the scales to effective Democratic rule of the US gov’t and both our major parties can be truly center-left/right parties!

  2. Brian Opsahl

    Three thing’s here…?

    One) this bill will never be brought before the house thank’s to republicans in Congress.
    Two) the bill as writen even if it was past not a single illegeal immigrant would follow or use it.
    Third) Democrats will use this as a slege hammer issue in the next election cycle….and the republicans are to stupid to do anything about it…just like the last time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *