Congressional Republicans have no X, no Y and no Z


Jonathan Bernstein NAILS IT:

Republicans have mostly just given up on developing real, conservative public policy. We saw that in the 2012 campaign, in which Mitt Romney couldn’t be bothered to come up with a tax plan that came close to adding up. We’ve seen it in the failure to come up with a “replace” bill on healthcare reform as part of their promised “repeal and replace” plan. Unlike in Ronald Reagan’s era, or even Newt Gingrich’s era (or perhaps more to the point, unlike in Jimmy Carter or Bill Clinton’s presidency), there’s no conservative policy agenda beyond just rejecting everything Democrats want.

Simply put: When you’ve reduced your entire movement to saying “no” to Barack Obama and Nancy Pelosi, is it any surprise that whoever shouts “NO” the loudest will wind up defining what counts as “conservative”?

Indeed, if you happen to be a demagogue running for president on the platform that you are the only True Conservative and everyone else is a squish or a RINO or a secret liberal, then the best plan is to find the most convoluted, self-destructive, but nevertheless very loud way of saying “no.” Which is basically what Ted Cruz and his allies have done with the demand that Republicans tie keeping the government open to defunding the ACA.

See, it doesn’t have to be this way. Imagine if Republicans approached the budget deadline this year with a substantial policy program. Perhaps they would have already passed a tax reform bill, or an immigration bill that they wanted to pass, even if it wasn’t what Democrats wanted. Perhaps it would be a comprehensive energy bill (and not just a slogan, which is what the Keystone pipeline basically is). Maybe they would have come up with a housing plan. Maybe all of those. They would have run on those programs in the first place, spent a lot of time and energy on them; they would have argued that those programs were what conservative action was all about in 2013. Not just members of the House, either; conservative think tanks and GOP-aligned interest groups would have invested resources in those programs. Many of those in the GOP-aligned media would have spent the year, and perhaps the campaign last year, talking about conservative innovation and conservative vitality and how that agenda, blocked by Obama and the Democrats, truly defined conservative thought.

Under those circumstances, Republicans really would have had something positive to fight for in the budget showdown, rather than just threaten to hold their breath until they turned blue unless Democrats repealed the ACA. But more important, cranks who suggested that strategy would have far less of a claim on being the real True Conservatives. Republican politicians would have a way to fight back – yes, they could say, we’re all against Obamacare, but real conservatives are fighting for X, Y and Z.

But there is no X, no Y and no Z. And that’s part of the reason why when Ted Cruz (or Rush Limbaugh, or anyone else who can plausibly claim to be a True Conservative) tells the party to head for the cliff, they start in that direction and may well still go right over.



1 Comment

  1. Well, to be fair Republicans finally submitted a health plan of their own. Details here:


    Of course, none of the Republicans leaders (Boehner, Cantor, Ryan, McConnell, Priebus) are really pushing the plan, so it is debatable how serious they are.

    Bernstein also appears to have completely forgotten about the Ryan Roadmap for America plan, which is the only major plan seem by either party in over a decade that balances the budget.

    Unfortunately, Bernstein is correct in that the party voices appears to be ran by the obstructionists. This whole “Defunding” thing is a terrible strategy.

    A smarter solution would have been to dismantle PPACA into pieces. There are several items that could be removed with bipartisan support. The tax on medical device manufacturers, the newly established health care review boards, and the minimum spending requires all could have been eliminated by now. Even when the Supreme Court gave the thumbs up to to insurance mandates, there should have been a bill submitted the next day to strip it out.

    Instead, the Republican “all or nothing” tactic has failed miserably by dividing the party, and hurting their chances on relection.

    It’s time for some new Republican leadership. Boehner, McConnell, Cantor, Priebus. All need to go.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *