Farewell, Firefly. We hardly knew ye.
2 comments December 15th, 2008
For nearly 70 years, the Mayflower was a fine-dining staple on North Second Street in Loves Park. Since the original Mayflower closed in January 1999, several restaurant groups have tried and failed to build a succesful business in the still-stylish building. The latest effort, the Firefly, closed earlier this month and the building is back up for lease.
Here’s the timeline of the Mayflower evolution:
- The Mayflower was open from the early 1930s until January 1999
- Reopened Nov. 1, 1999, by Todd LaMere as LaMere’s Mayflower.
- Todd LaMere changed the name to LaMere’s North in October of 2000 but closed abruptly in May 2001.
- In May 2002, the owner of the Morning Glory Restaurant reopens the Mayflower under its historic name.
- Sometime between 2002 and 2005 there was The Cave, a NASCAR-themed restaurant that escaped Register Star attention.
- In 2005, it reopened as JRichard’s Mayflower and closed in July 2007.
- This January, the Nuttall family bought the building – all the other attempts were leasing the building – with a menu leaning toward healthy eating.

