One more WATCHMEN review
2 comments March 6th, 2009
I’m posting a link to Jeffrey Wells’ review over at his site, HOLLYWOOD ELSEWHERE, because he seemed completely primed to hate this movie, taking every opportunity to take potshots at it in the months leading up to the opening, then when he finally saw it, well…
“WATCHMEN Â may or may not be your cup of tea (it’s not mine) but at least it was made by a kind of madman who gave as little quarter as possible and didn’t muck around. I almost love the fact that WATCHMEN doesn’t try to make you feel “good,” and that it just tries to be itself.
I emerged from the theatre feeling subdued but not seething inside. WATCHMEN never put a real smile on my face, but neither did it make me sit forward and groan and spread my fingers across my face. Yes, it frequently turned me off and sometimes inspired feelings of deep loathing. It provided almost nothing in the way of whole-hog satisfaction, but at least it left me feeling that I’d seen something different.”
I appreciate Wells’ honesty, admitting a movie he didn’t think he’d like at all has something to recommend it. And I like how he sorts out his feelings during the actual review (something he does a lot on his sometimes-infuriating-but-always-worth-reading site). In a world of four-star-or-no-star reviews, sharing mixed feelings about a movie is refreshing.
If all goes according to plan, I’ll see it Saturday night and post something here Sunday. If you see it, please swing by and post your thoughts in the comments.


